Binnington made 28 saves for the Blues (20-20-4), who have lost three of four.
“The lack of urgency in our group is what’s hurting us in our consistency,” St. Louis coach Jim Montgomery said. “You look at the way we came out against Anaheim (in a 6-2 win on Thursday), there was a direct purpose to what we were doing. Tonight there was not. It was wait and see. And that urgency [of] us fearing losing is something that’s got to become part of our fiber if we want to get to the consistent level we want to be at.”
Fantilli gave Columbus a 1-0 lead at 15:38 of the first period. Kirill Marchenko found him open in front with a pass from the right face-off circle, and Fantilli scored around Binnington.
“I thought [Marchenko] was shooting it,” Fantilli said. “I know when he has the puck in those areas, I have to be ready for it because he could be faking it and he could be slipping it. I’ve just got to stay ready in there and it ended up coming. The fake was so good that Binnington wasn’t in the net there and it worked out.”
Sillinger made it 2-0 with a power-play goal at 16:51 of the second period. He scored with a one-timer from in close off James van Riemsdyk’s pass from behind the net.
“To make it 2-0 going into the third period, going out to a two-goal lead was key,” Sillinger said.