Mathieu Olivier scored in the third period to end a scoreless drought of 182:55 for the Blue Jackets (31-28-8), who have lost four straight and six of seven. Jet Greaves made 18 saves.
Despite the loss, Columbus coach Dean Evason was impressed by the performance.
“It was freaking awesome,” he said. “Did we get the result? No. Did we play the right way? Do we believe that this is the turning point? Do we believe that this, not only the (third) period, the game, turns us around and we're ready to go forward? Yeah, 100 percent.
“We had so many unbelievable opportunities. We played the right way, we played hard, we played disciplined, we played within the system structurally. We just didn't get the result.”
The Devils are six points behind the Carolina Hurricanes for second place in the Metropolitan Division. The Blue Jackets remained two points behind the New York Rangers, who have played one more game, for the second wild card in the Eastern Conference.
“A desperate opponent coming at us,” Devils coach Sheldon Keefe said. “They're real aggressive, lots of pressure, hard to make any real tape-to-tape passes in that environment, so you're under siege. But goaltending was terrific from Jake Allen.
“I thought the guys, despite giving one up, that's sort of the bend don’t break type mentality, and we earned two points off of that mentality.”
Meier gave the Devils a 1-0 lead at 13:35 of the second period, skating past Dante Fabbro through the left circle before putting a backhand five-hole on Greaves.