The Sabres appeared to have taken a two-goal lead at 8:02 when a video review determined that the puck had crossed the goal line when Dobes caught Jack Quinn’s shot. But Montreal successfully challenged that Buffalo rookie forward Konsta Helenius, who was making his Stanley Cup Playoff debut, interfered with Dobes on the play.
Newhook then tied it 1-1 at 10:08 with his sixth goal of the playoffs. He drove to the slot to take Jake Evans’ backhand pass from behind the goal line and snap a shot past Luukkonen.
Caufield put Montreal up 2-1 with a power-play goal at 19:47. He took a pass from Juraj Slafkovsky to the left of the net and skated in along the goal line before slipping a shot under Luukkonen’s left pad.
“We broke them down a bunch, had our looks,” Caufield said. “Their goalie made some big saves, kept them in it.”
Thompson tied it 2-2 with a power-play goal at 7:00 of the second period. His dump-in took an odd bounce off a stanchion along the boards on the left side and went in off Dobes’ right pad.
“Sometimes you want to just keep it simple, rim it, and try to get on the forecheck,” Thompson said. “I rimmed it and obviously saw it hit the glass and saw, kind of just scanned around looking for it and then a few guys put their hands up. So it’s a nice feeling when you see that.”
Said Suzuki, “We battled our way back to get the lead in the first, and then I thought the second period we controlled it pretty well. We just couldn’t find that next goal.”
NOTES: Benson is the 13th player in NHL history, and first Sabres player, to score a game-winning goal in the playoffs on his birthday. … Helenius played 12:53 and had three shots on goal. … Defenseman Luke Schenn played 7:04 and had two blocked shots in his Buffalo playoff debut. … Thompson, who has 11 points (four goals, seven assists) in 10 games in the playoffs, is the sixth Sabres player to record at least 10 points in his first 10 playoff games. The others: Gilbert Perreault (six games), Tim Connolly (seven games), Pierre Turgeon (seven games), Rene Robert (seven games) and Rick Martin (10 games). … Caufield scored his 31st go-ahead goal of the regular season and playoffs combined, moving past Joe Sakic (30 in 1995-96 and 2000-01) for the fourth-most in NHL history. Brett Hull scored 42 go-ahead goals during the 1990-91 regular season and playoffs; Wayne Gretzky (1984-85) and Leon Draisaitl (2024-25) each scored 32.