Early in the season, people said the Predators needed to blow it up and start over. Now they're a few points out of a playoff spot. What should they do at the deadline? -- @punmasterrifkin
The Nashville Predators signed forwards Steven Stamkos and Jonathan Marchessault, and defenseman Brady Skjei, on July 1, 2024, with the expectation of being a playoff team right away and at least for a few years. They did not meet those expectations last season. They have a chance this season. They should stay the course and see if they can get there, and if they can do some damage when they're in. They know as well as any team in the League the importance of just getting in. They did that in 2017 and ended up in the Stanley Cup Final, so it can be done.
If we're being totally fair and honest, the Predators are not as good as the Avalanche, Minnesota Wild, Dallas Stars or Edmonton Oilers, so their chances of advancing in the playoffs aren't great. They weren't as good as the Chicago Blackhawks in 2017, and yet they won the best-of-7 Western Conference First Round in a four-game sweep. That they're not as good in the regular season as the Avalanche, Wild, Stars, Golden Knights or Oilers doesn't matter. Every single one of the Predators' impact players from Stamkos to Marchessault, Filip Forsberg, Ryan O'Reilly, Roman Josi, Skjei and goalie Juuse Saros are signed beyond this season. They're not pending UFAs who the Predators have to make decisions on, so keep them, go for it, see if they can get in, ride it and then reevaluate in the offseason.
The one thing the Predators should not do is trade prospects or high draft picks for rental players. They're not in that category. That's reserved for teams like the Avalanche, Wild, Stars, Oilers and Golden Knights. If the Predators can get a depth player on an expiring contract for a mid-round pick or a middle-level prospect, that's fine. They have 16 picks in rounds 2-5 of the next two drafts, but it doesn't make sense for them to trade significant parts of their future for an immediate fix.